Volume 31, Number 12

June 19, 2009

Dear Client:

One of the least-discussed aspects of getting a home loan is becoming an impediment to an efficient closing of a home sale in the Austin area between a willing seller and a willing buyer.

This scenario is being replicated daily in the Austin area: A home seller and a home buyer go through the normal negotiations and agree on a price. The home buyer is pre-approved for a loan to cover the purchase. The home is inspected and the seller and buyer once again agree to make the deal. The lender requires a 3^rd-party appraisal. All well and good, so far. But the appraisal process is turning out to be a big hitch in the closing process.

Appraisals in and of themselves are a good thing. But the process is causing real problems for Austin buyers and sellers. It ratcheted up to a new level 5/1/09, when a new national Home Valuation Code was adopted. The Code bars loan officers, mortgage brokers or real estate agents from any role in selecting appraisers for mortgages that will be owned or guaranteed by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac

As a result, many lenders are outsourcing the selection to appraisal-management companies (that take a big slice of the appraisal fee). Some companies put appraisers under pressure to do it faster and do it cheaper. Experienced appraisers are turning down requests to pay them only 50% to 70% of their fees and may also include a requirement the appraisal be completed in as little as 48 hours.

This process has resulted in such anomalies as appraisers being hired from outside Travis County to conduct appraisals in neighborhoods they don’t know very well. The end result: less accuracy and certainty about a property’s true value.

And no one can discuss the appraisal with the appraiser under this new Code.

Anecdotally, you can find examples where some of these appraisals are challenged regularly. (No hard numbers are available) Home values differ from neighborhood to neighborhood, street-by-street. And in many cases no current comparable sales exist. This is where an appraiser who knows the area can more accurately appraise the home’s true value – more so than an appraiser from out-of-area who is charged with doing a “quick” turnaround.

This causes a number of problems, including the possibility a buyer must seek another appraisal. It is slowing sales and as the sales pace picks up, the problems may increase.

Ok. check my post previously where one of my clients got rogered… HVCC rant I hate to say it, but, “I told you so.”

joe